The episode picks up right where last week’s shocking reveal left off—the child killer and Nikky’s kidnapper have been unmasked. If you haven’t seen the previous episode, consider this your spoiler warning.
We open with a gloved hand, crushing pills into a water bottle. Moments later, poor Nikky, starving and desperate, gulps down the tainted drink, oblivious to the danger. The kidnapper returns, and in his drugged haze, Nikky instinctively calls him "Dad." The camera pans up to reveal the culprit—Captain Spencer. Just like that, Dexter’s suspicions are confirmed.
Meanwhile, Deb is nowhere to be found at the Morgan household. Dexter casually mentions that she’s with Gio, prompting an immediate reaction from Harry. Harry orders Dexter to find her once he learns that Gio is far too old for Deb. But Dexter has other things on his mind—namely, his mounting suspicions about Captain Spencer. Harry shuts him down, accusing Dexter of letting his dark passenger cloud his judgment, twisting facts to justify his cravings. He knows the captain personally and was just at Nikky’s confirmation. It is absurd to Harry that Dexter would even suspect Spencer.
Elsewhere, Deb is tangled up in Gio’s satin sheets, pretending to be the adult she’s not. Gio is headed on a "business trip," and when Deb confesses that she was suspended from school, he barely reacts. Instead, he offers to take her along. This grown man is perfectly fine dating a teenage high schooler—where are the cops when you need them?
Dexter swings by the high school, looking for answers. While we’re on the subject, let's not forget that Dexter himself, though younger than Gio, was also dating a high schooler. He checks in with Sofia, concerned about Deb’s disappearance.
Meanwhile, Harry picks up LaGuerta, giving us a glimpse of Miguel Prado, a nostalgic callback for fans of the original series. Over their conversation, Harry vents about Deb’s situation. At 17, she might legally be able to date a 25-year-old in certain states, but it’s still creepy. LaGuerta reminisces about her rebellious days, assuring Harry that no matter how far she strayed, she always found her way home.
The flashbacks continue, though one glaring omission remains: Dexter’s brother, Bryan. He’s an essential part of the Dexter story, yet these sequences rarely acknowledge him. Hopefully, that changes next season. In another memory, Harry reassures Laura, but she tells him she can’t keep holding on. His attachment to Dexter seems deeply rooted in the loss of his son. Unbeknownst to them, the cartel is watching, and just like that, Laura’s cover is blown.
At the station, Captain Spencer puts on a convincing performance, but Dexter isn’t buying it. Still, to appease Harry, he shifts his focus to finding Deb. Spencer, sensing Dexter’s growing suspicions, attempts to bury him in cold cases. It’s a weak distraction—Dexter already found blood evidence that could crack the kidnapping case wide open. Intrigued, he starts tailing the captain, but in the process, he begins questioning his own instincts.
While Dexter hunts for answers, Deb lives it up on Gio’s yacht, sipping champagne like she’s in an MTV special. But as Dexter’s pursuit intensifies, Harry drops an urgent 911 text. Dexter reports that Sofia told him Deb did not want to be found. However, he sees the captain acting suspiciously, but Harry explodes, refusing to hear it.
Another flashback brings us back to Laura. Cartel members storm into her home, and before we can process the implications, we’re abruptly back to Gio’s lavish lifestyle. He introduces Deb to his friends, and suddenly, his "business trip" looks less like corporate travel and more like international crime. As Rico Suave plays in the background, Deb stumbles upon drugs, partying, and a shady exchange while going to get water. She spots crates being loaded onto Gio’s boat. It doesn’t take a detective to realize what’s going on—Gio isn’t just dating high schoolers, he’s drug trafficking.
Meanwhile, Dexter tracks down Gio’s house and meets his adult fiancé. Yes, fiancé—because, of course, this guy is engaged while parading Deb around like a trophy.
Back at the station, Harry and LaGuerta’s case leads them to a box of files. As Harry sifts through them, he is horrified. One of the files contains records on Laura, and he’s identified as her lover. Just as LaGuerta reenters the room, Harry discreetly swipes the file. He flashes back to the day of Laura’s murder, arriving at her home only to find it eerily empty. Laura and the children have been taken. Cut to them crammed into a boxcar with other cartel victims, sealing her tragic fate.
Deb’s fantasy with Gio crumbles fast. She snoops around his yacht, discovering things she shouldn’t, and when he catches her, he doesn’t bother with pleasantries—he kicks her off the boat, leaving her stranded on a dark beach alone. Lucky for her,
Dexter finds her in time. Still rattled, she chucks the diamond bracelet Gio gave her into the ocean, only to immediately regret it because, as she laments, she could’ve pawned it. They return home, and Deb, in true Deb fashion, decides the best way to recover from a near-death experience is to order pizza. But Dexter’s not done for the night—duty calls, leaving Deb alone with her terrible choices and regret.
The episode closes with a SWAT raid on a suspected cartel hideout where they believe Nikky is being held. Dexter is now convinced he was wrong about the captain and watches as the team moves in. But the audience knows better. The house is empty—no Nikky, no traffickers. They find only his jersey, a chilling reminder that the boy is still missing. Before the dust settles, a shootout erupts, possibly costing Detective Bobby his life.
As Dexter watches Captain Spencer closely, reality clicks into place. He wasn’t wrong. The darkness he’s always sought—the thing that he can see in the killers he hunts—he sees it now. He sees it in the captain.
Another gripping episode that lays the groundwork for Bryan Moser’s storyline—whose file Harry now has. It’ll be fascinating to see how that thread unfolds next season. Ten out of ten.
What did you think?
Loved it
Hated it
So/So
Comments